EVIDENCE REVIEW

THE CLAIMS

Before a verdict comes the original wording, full context, measurement, counterevidence and a reproducible source trail.

PHASE 06 / EVIDENCE REVIEW

CLAIM AUTOPSY / PUBLISHED RECORDS

These are discrete, source-scoped documentary examinations—not a rating of any senator or a live social-media feed. A single post can give rise to multiple testable questions. Original post access limitations remain visible in each record.

17Documentary reviews
6Source statements
40Distinct documentary URLs

17 matching claim files

CLAIM FILE / 2026-10-09fact check

The scope of Democratic participation

Chuck Grassley · X statement capture

What does the committee record show about Democrats participating in Arctic Frost oversight, and what remains disputed?

2 dated source references · 1 revision entry OPEN DOSSIER →
CLAIM FILE / 2026-10-09fact check

The October 2025 committee invitation

Chuck Grassley · X statement capture

Did the chairman publicly ask Democratic colleagues to join his Arctic Frost inquiry in October 2025?

2 dated source references · 1 revision entry OPEN DOSSIER →
CLAIM FILE / 2026-10-08fact check

When did the inflation surge accelerate?

John Kennedy · X statement capture

Does the chronology establish a 2021 inflation acceleration, and does chronology alone prove a sole presidential cause?

4 dated source references · 1 revision entry OPEN DOSSIER →
CLAIM FILE / 2026-09-29mediation

Two documented basketball games

Amy Klobuchar · X statement capture

Were the Maryland college game and Atlanta NBA game distinct events, and what does that prove about testimony?

4 dated source references · 1 revision entry OPEN DOSSIER →
CLAIM FILE / 2026-09-29mediation

The request for an apology

Amy Klobuchar · X statement capture

What is directly documented about the hearing exchange and the request for an apology?

2 dated source references · 1 revision entry OPEN DOSSIER →

CLAIM AUTOPSY FRAMEWORK

01Preserve the statementRecord the author, venue, exact words, publication date and source status.
02Make the proposition testableIdentify the relevant metric, denominator, dates, comparisons and implied meaning.
03Reconstruct the evidenceUse primary records, reproduce the calculation, document conflicts and caveats.
04Publish the supported findingExplain what holds, what does not, what remains unknown and the correction/right-of-reply record.
OPEN A COMPLETE DEMO

READ FROM THE EDITORIAL DESK

ALL REPORTING

PUBLIC FIGURE EVIDENCE REVIEWS

Reviews of people outside the current Senate/governor roster are tracked in a separate, speaker-owned registry.

David Pyne: Did Zelenskyy identify an American-flagged tanker and direct an attack?

David Pyne: Was Russian oil already purchased by the United States and aboard a specific tanker?

David Pyne: Did the quoted remarks themselves establish an act of war against the United States?

David Pyne: Was a binding U.S.-Russia-Ukraine peace settlement already signed for Ukraine to accept?

David Pyne: Could a president immediately turn off every Starlink terminal and every form of U.S. Ukraine aid?

Ilhan Omar: Did the October 8 Trump statement collectively characterize Somali Minnesotans?

Ilhan Omar: Were Omar’s warnings about possible community safety consequences grounded in contemporaneous responses?

Ilhan Omar: Does the record establish that Minnesota was being taken over by Somali immigrants?

Mike Pence: Does the evidence support an unqualified finding that Ukraine is winning the war?