EDITORIAL STANDARDS / DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE

HOW CLAIM AUTOPSY WORKS

The X capture, factual proposition, burden of proof, documents, contrary context, date scope, and transparent revision history stay together.

Phase 06 operating boundary

Each record belongs to one Phase 05 source statement and one permanent politician identity. When an article references other officials, that does not make them the original speaker.

Our seven possible classifications describe specific propositions, not an official’s overall honesty or suitability for office. The initial Phase 06 evidence dossiers publish source-limited reasoning without applying categorical political labels. No system-generated judgment is final.

Manual classification rubric for future fully adjudicated factual reviews
ClassificationScope and requirement
SupportedThe evidence presented would support the narrowly worded factual proposition, with cited scope.
Accurate but incompleteThe narrow statement may be accurate while relevant, material context is omitted.
MisleadingA review documents that presentation or framing conveys an implication not supported by identified facts.
ContradictedReliable records directly conflict with a specific, testable proposition.
UnsupportedThe cited material cannot substantiate the requested proposition.
UnresolvedEvidence is missing, inaccessible, or credibly conflicting.
Opinion / rhetoricThe proposition is primarily advocacy, an opinion, or a request, not a falsifiable factual assertion.

Evidence versus inference

Official source pages can establish dates, text, votes and individual statements. They do not necessarily establish intentions, causation, private negotiations, illegality or whether a reader-supplied X screenshot matches an independently retrieved post.

All public claims disclose when the underlying X content was not directly recovered. Alternative accounts are attributed, and procedural votes are distinguished from substantive enactment.

Manual publishing procedure

A research bot prepares offline draft JSON, collects a dated source-check ledger and preserves original material in the private development archive. Approved records receive a stable file ID and a public page; the publisher deploys a complete static ZIP. No D1, R2, public editor, sign-in form or writing endpoint is required.

BROWSE REVIEWED CLAIMS → · RESPONSES & CORRECTIONS →